I followed the instructions to the letter and found that the neckline was very floppy and just a little too wide. It's more obvious in the picture below. The pattern calls for 9 stitches to be cast on for the button and buttonhole bands. But that was just too much.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/63de5/63de5f76a2c2e141566c8d2a0b65a2073b2658cf" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2057a/2057a1f637c54892d4c092143650d00af77dbb15" alt=""
So what am I to do?? Frog the collar and the button/buttonhole bands and reknit the whole darn thing. Instead of 9 stitches I made the bands 7 stitches. I also incorporated 8 knit togethers (evenly spaced through out the neckline) on the row after picking up the stitches for the collar. Much happier. The collar is definitely less wide and floppy. Now I have to find 3 buttons and block the cr*p out of the rolling button bands. I'm sure it's a design feature but it's annoying me. Sorry for the crap photo but it's been pouring in London during today.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9e2f0/9e2f01729bcec0439fb19bea146207cdcc2f242e" alt=""
Pattern notes
Pattern - Kay from Rowan 40
Yarn - 6 balls of Rowan Big Wool in Latte, pattern calls for 7 balls
Modifications - described above. I also don't think I'm going to put in the leaves from the pattern.
Overall - pretty happy with this knit, especially with the weather turning decidedly wintery!!